Discussion 1 : Academic Values and Professional Ethics – A Comparison
The first sentence of the Preamble to the Code of Ethics of the National Association of Social Workers states that â€œthe primary mission of the social work profession is to enhance human well-being and help meet the basic human needs of all people…â€ (NASW, 2008). This statement very much aligns with the Walden University mission that as an institution â€œâ€¦provides a diverse community of career professionals with the opportunity to transform themselves as scholar-practitioners so that they can effect positive social changeâ€ (Walden University, 2013). Social workers are often called change agents as they address the needs of marginalized and oppressed groups, by enacting change on many different levels. How might Walden Universityâ€™s mission and vision compliment the social work code of ethics? How might you be able to meld the two together to become your own social change agent?
1. Post an explanation of the similarities between social work core values and the Walden Mission and Vision.
2. Describe the potential ethical dilemma you identified from the course-specific case study you selected.
3. Then explain the decision you might make in response to that ethical dilemma. Include an explanation of how the Walden Mission and Vision and the principles you selected from the NASW ethical standards influenced your decision.
4. Finally, explain how the mission, vision, and values might inform your role as a social change agent.
Support your posts and responses with specific references to the Resources. Be sure to provide full APA citations for your references.
- Kirst-Ashman, K. K., & Hull, G. H., Jr. (2015). Understanding generalist practice (6th ed.). Stamford, CT: Cengage Learning.
- Chapter 11, “Values, Ethics, and the Resolution of Ethical Dilemmas” (pp. 395-441)
- National Association of Social Workers. (2008). Code of ethics of the National Association of Social workers. Retrieved from http://www.naswdc.org/pubs/code/code.asp
- Plummer, S.-B., Makris, S., & Brocksen S. M. (Eds.). (2014). Social work case studies: Foundation year.Baltimore, MD: Laureate International Universities Publishing. [Vital Source e-reader].
- Working with Survivors of Domestic Violence: The Case of Debra
- Working with Clients with HIV/AIDS: The Case of Pedro
- [removed]Walden University. (n.d.). Mission and vision. Retrieved June 16, 2013, from http://waldenu.edu/about/social-change/mission-and-vision
Working With Clients With HIV/AIDS: The Case of Pedro
Pedro is a 58-year-old, heterosexual, Dominican male who is HIV positive. He is married to his second wife and is the father of three sons. Pedro lives with his wife in a modest two-bedroom apartment in a major metropolitan area. Pedro completed high school and has a long work history as the manager of multiple food stores in his community. Pedro is currently on disability. He collects Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) and is covered by Medicare and the AIDS Drug Assistance Program (ADAP). ADAP is a state-sponsored insurance program for low-income individuals with HIV/AIDS that provides assistance with access to medication and primary care services in the state. Pedro does some work â€œoff the booksâ€ to keep himself busy and earn extra money. While Spanish is Pedroâ€™s dominant language, he is able to communicate well in English. Pedro identifies as a Christian, and his faith is a very important part of his life.
Pedro has a long history of substance abuse, including intravenous drug use (IVDU). Pedro spent a good part of 20 years using both cocaine and heroin. Despite his drug use, Pedro kept a full-time job and provided a safe home and moderate lifestyle for his family. When I met Pedro, he had been clean for more than 15 years. He reported that he stopped using drugs â€œbecause I got tired of being strung out.â€ He stated, â€œOne day I grabbed my Bible and locked myself in a room for a week. I havenâ€™t touched drugs since.â€ Pedro denied ever attending a formal drug rehabilitation program.
Pedro was diagnosed HIV positive in 1988. His risk factor for contracting HIV was IVDU. Pedroâ€™s first wife contracted HIV from Pedro and died of AIDS. After her death, Pedro raised his sons as a single parent until he remarried about 10 years later. Pedroâ€™s youngest son was infected with HIV through vertical transmission (from mother to baby). His HIV disease was controlled until he was 17. At that time, Pedroâ€™s son developed AIDS and, after a long battle, died before his 19th birthday. Pedro never left his sonâ€™s bedside during his illness. Pedro harbors significant guilt about his sonâ€™s death. Pedroâ€™s HIV/AIDS is moderately controlled on highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART), although he has a history of poor compliance with his HAART regimen. HAART should be taken on a consistent schedule, but Pedro stops and starts his HAART, which can be very dangerous. In addition to HIV/AIDS, Pedro is diagnosed with hepatitis C (Hep C). His doctor has indicated that Pedroâ€™s Hep C should be treated, but Pedro is very reluctant to begin treatment.
The treatment setting where I met Pedro was an outpatient comprehensive care clinic affiliated with a city hospital. The clinic was created to provide interdisciplinary care to adult patients living with HIV/AIDS. The backbone of each patientâ€™s clinical team included a social worker and a primary care physician with a specialty in HIV care. For the most part, visits with the social worker were paired with routine doctor appointments. When I met Pedro, he was an established patient at the clinic, having gone there since his initial diagnosis in 1988. As a result, he had worked with a string of social workers over the years.
During our initial visit, Pedro greeted me by saying, â€œI really donâ€™t need another social worker who is not going to help me, so thereâ€™s no point in me talking to you.â€ I urged Pedro to sit down with me so I could at least introduce myself. During our visit, I validated Pedroâ€™s feelings about having another new social worker and attempted to explain how I viewed my role at the clinic. Pedro â€œyessed me to deathâ€ politely, but his ambivalence and resistance were palpable. This type of exchange continued for several visits. During these visits, I tried to build a rapport with Pedro. We spoke about his family and his social and medical history. The visits were casual, and I was nonconfrontational. After each visit, I thanked Pedro for talking to me and told him that I hoped I would be able to help him if something came up. My intent during this period was to build a clinical assessment of Pedro. Pedro had a strong personality and was reluctant to show his true emotions. His presentation was consistent with machismo, and I realized that Pedroâ€™s Latino cultural background was embedded throughout his life. Pedro was profoundly committed to his family and their well-being, he had strong views toward male and female gender roles, and religion played a very important role in Pedroâ€™s life.
One day, Pedro surprised me by greeting me and saying, â€œOk, I need your help.â€ Pedro was having difficulty filling his prescriptions. In short, Pedroâ€™s Medicare and ADAP had to work together, but neither Pedro nor the pharmacy could figure out how to make the process work. It became plainly obvious that despite Pedroâ€™s ability to manage many complex issues in his life, dealing with this issue was overwhelming and almost paralyzing for him. After multiple phone calls to Medicare, ADAP, the pharmacy, etc., I was able to decipher the process that Pedro needed to follow. I realized the only way Pedro was going to be able to succeed was if I broke the problem down into manageable pieces. Ultimately, Pedro and I figured out a suitable plan that worked for him and got his prescriptions filled. While my initial task was to help Pedro come up with a plan of action, my ongoing role was to provide support and encouragement so that Pedro felt empowered to face a task that was once inapproachable.
Engaging Pedro around this concrete issue opened the door to our future relationship. In his eyes, I was no longer â€œanother worthless social worker,â€ and he was able to address more emotional issues with me, such as his feelings about his sonâ€™s death and the progression of his own HIV/AIDS and Hep C illnesses. In our future work, we spoke about Pedroâ€™s noncompliance to his medication, and while Pedroâ€™s behaviors around his HAART did not change, he did begin and successfully complete treatment for his Hep C.